Advertisement 1

John Ivison: India is a prize worth winning if Trudeau is serious about building trade relations

India could be integral, as part of a broader post-NAFTA risk mitigation strategy. But the PM should be careful to avoid presenting it as the Next Big Thing

Get the latest from John Ivison straight to your inbox

Article content

OTTAWA — Justin Trudeau will head to India next month, thus affirming the old proverb that if you cannot have a bird of paradise, you better take a wet hen.

That’s not a shot at India. There are many good reasons for the prime minister to visit the sub-continent, not least the chance to ingratiate himself with 1.6 million Indo-Canadians 18 months before a general election.

Advertisement 2
Story continues below
Article content

But Canada’s volume of trade with India is not large enough to offer much relief should President Donald Trump follow through on his threat to undo the North American Free Trade Agreement.

Article content

Opening free trade talks with China, a country with which we have a $60-billion trading relationship, would have created major opportunities for Canadian exporters. But that prospect has dimmed for now, following the prime minister’s presumptuous demand that the Chinese agree to more exacting labour standards than the Communist regime could stomach.

Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau departs Ottawa for Davos, Switzerland on Monday, January 22, 2018.
Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau departs Ottawa for Davos, Switzerland on Monday, January 22, 2018. Photo by THE CANADIAN PRESS/Paul Chiasson

The Trans-Pacific Partnership, which includes Japan, would provide a welcome alternative for Canadian business, particularly for its farmers.

But Canada is the lone hold-out among the 11 remaining signatories, concerned over the impact of a deal on its cultural and auto industries.

The emphasis on a “progressive” trade agenda that insists on the inclusion of chapters on labour, the environment and Aboriginal and gender rights, has infuriated potential trading partners, including the Americans.

Having struck out around the globe, Trudeau is now set to attempt to woo Indian Prime Minister, Narendra Modi.

Article content
Advertisement 3
Story continues below
Article content

India could be integral, as part of a broader post-NAFTA risk mitigation strategy.

Justin Trudeau speaks at Montreal’s annual India day parade in 2017. His upcoming trip to India will win him some favour with with 1.6 million Indo-Canadians, John Ivison suggests.
Justin Trudeau speaks at Montreal’s annual India day parade in 2017. His upcoming trip to India will win him some favour with with 1.6 million Indo-Canadians, John Ivison suggests. Photo by Graham Hughes/The Canadian Press
Recommended from Editorial
  1. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau meets with US President Donald Trump in the Oval Office of the White House in Washington, DC on Monday, Feb. 13, 2017.
    Ahead of new NAFTA talks, U.S. is angry and frustrated with Canada for being obstructionist
  2. Trade Minister François-Philippe Champagne.
    Canada to attend first Trans-Pacific Partnership meeting since Trudeau's APEC no-show
  3. Prime Minister Justin Trudeau speaks at a town hall event at Western University in London, Ont., on Thursday, January 11, 2018.
    Discussions afoot about reworking Canada's 'progressive trade agenda'

But the prime minister should be careful to avoid presenting it as the Next Big Thing.

Having followed the progress of Canada’s trade relationship with India over the past decade, here are a number of observations.

One, our trade with India is rising dramatically, particularly in services, but at $8 billion in two-way trade, it barely breaks into our Top 10 partners and accounts for less than one per cent of our exports.

Two, the relationship has been promising for a long time, but it turns out to be largely a relationship of promises.

When Modi met Stephen Harper in Ottawa in 2015, he pledged a “road map” for a free trade agreement within six months. But there remain stubborn impediments to progress, not least the Indian desire to secure labour mobility for their millions of cost-competitive white-collar workers – a problem for any Canadian government, given recent controversies over temporary foreign workers. One more round of negotiations will be completed on talks that opened in 2010, so anything is possible. But the relationship has long under-delivered and few people expect a break-through will be made next month.

Advertisement 4
Story continues below
Article content

Third, Modi is unlikely to be any more receptive than the Chinese or Japanese to Trudeau’s insistence on imposing the Liberal agenda in areas where the domestic circumstance makes reform problematic.

Is it a courtesy call or is it truly about kick-starting a legitimate trade discussion?

Goldy Hyder

Goldy Hyder, the Indian-born chief executive of Hill & Knowlton Strategies Canada, said it makes sense for Trudeau to hedge his bets by travelling to India, thus sending the signal to the Americans that Canada is moving on.

But, he said Trudeau cannot repeat the Chinese experience of lecturing the Indians about human rights in their own country. “We need them more than they need us,” he said. “The world’s at their door.”

Fourth, as The Economist pointed out in a lengthy essay last week, while enthusiasm for India is boundless, the returns have fallen short of the hype. Report after report points to 300-400 million Indians in the ranks of the global middle class, yet relatively few have money to spend. The Chinese own five times as many motor vehicles per head; 97 per cent of Indians have never flown; mean GDP per head is just US$1,700, with 80 per cent of the population earning less than that. The conclusion: those relying on India becoming the next consumer pivot are likely to be disappointed.

Advertisement 5
Story continues below
Article content

As Hyder pointed out, Canada is well-positioned to take advantage of the opportunities that do exist in areas like finance, infrastructure (Canadian pension funds have invested $15 billion) and education (with 124,000 students here, India is Canada’s second-largest source of foreign students).

“We see the visit as deepening and broadening our strategic partnership,” said Vikas Swarup, who as well as being India’s High Commissioner in Ottawa, is also famous for having written the book that became the movie Slumdog Millionaire.

“Canada’s financial and trade muscle will help us in a host of projects. We don’t receive bilateral aid but we are partners in areas ranging from energy to defence to security and counterterrormism,” he said.

Justin Trudeau with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in April 2016.
Justin Trudeau with Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi in April 2016. Photo by Sean Kilpatrick/The Canadian Press

But that deepening and broadening depends on whether the prime minister is serious about shoring up a relationship that is rather fragile right now – India recently decided to impose tariffs on Canadian pea imports because of record output.

“Is there a political agenda to this trip, is it a courtesy call or is it truly about kick-starting a legitimate trade discussion?” said Hyder.

Advertisement 6
Story continues below
Article content

More often than not, Canadian politicians have played footsie with their Indian counterparts to win votes at home.

Harper worked hard at winning the Indo-Canadian vote, through his 2008 apology for the Komagata Maru incident, in which Sikh immigrants were refused entry to Canada and sent back to Calcutta, and his 2009 and 2012 visits to India.

This prime minister has been no less brazen — the whole progressive trade agenda seems more focused on winning left-of-centre votes than on securing trade deals.

The long run success will depend on the visit stimulating bilateral relations, as part of a broader strategy to re-orient Canada as an Asia-Pacific trading nation.

In that event, the wet hen would be a prize worth winning.

• Email: jivison@nationalpost.com | Twitter:

Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark nationalpost.com and sign up for our politics newsletter, First Reading, here.

Article content
Get the latest from John Ivison straight to your inbox
Comments
You must be logged in to join the discussion or read more comments.
Join the Conversation

Postmedia is committed to maintaining a lively but civil forum for discussion. Please keep comments relevant and respectful. Comments may take up to an hour to appear on the site. You will receive an email if there is a reply to your comment, an update to a thread you follow or if a user you follow comments. Visit our Community Guidelines for more information.

Latest from Shopping Essentials
  1. Advertisement 2
    Story continues below
This Week in Flyers